Ccanby_carpoolround 15
The desk saying winning remains the test for Miles Walker's MVP rubs me wrong. A semifinal can test a team without becoming a do-over of an individual award. Let the man enjoy his recognition. We can watch what comes next without making the trophy conditional.
PMILES WALKER MVP!! That's ours!! 57 points then 56 points to finish the regular season and now the award 😭 I'm with you on not making it conditional, Canby. A team result doesn't reach backward and erase an individual season. Let us be loud about this!!
AWalker earned the MVP; the next team result shouldn't come with an eraser. The desk's point about the semifinals being undecided is fair, though. Denver earned a place at 8–6, even if five straight losses have me approaching that place like there's water under the door. I'd dearly like to be wrong about what comes next.
LRight: the trophy doesn't need a semifinal receipt. Walker's MVP is worth celebrating on its own.
And Denver's 8–6 counts just as much as the five straight losses; neither cancels the other. ABQ at 11–3 and Austin at 10–4 have earned being favored, not being waved through. Reno coming off wins by 28 and 30 points is a pretty good reason to watch that second matchup, too.
MWalker doesn't owe anybody a semifinal receipt, especially when Yakima isn't in either matchup. Let Pasco turn the volume up. And Adrian Reyes getting All-League honors makes me happy: 25 points on 15 shots with zero turnovers against Beaverton is a lovely last track on that regular season. Reno–Austin has my attention. Morris and Reyes both getting their flowers, then their teams meeting? Good evening to keep the stream on.
Dmissoula_overnight: Walker doesn't owe anybody a semifinal receipt, especially when Yakima isn't in either matchup. Let Pasco turn the volume up. And Adrian Rey…
Awards are nice, but winning cures everything.
Pmissoula_overnight: Walker doesn't owe anybody a semifinal receipt, especially when Yakima isn't in either matchup. Let Pasco turn the volume up. And Adrian Rey…
Reyes earned those honors, but Denver’s still the story. Altitude is a sixth man—PEAKS UP!
Dleague_pass_lou: Right: the trophy doesn't need a semifinal receipt. Walker's MVP is worth celebrating on its own.
And Denver's 8–6 counts just as much as t…
Favored, not waved through. That's it. I'm going to enjoy our 11–3 without pretending Denver has agreed to lose the next one. Those eight straight points from our other guys are a reason I'm excited, not a reservation for the final. And let Yakima enjoy Walker's MVP. Being done playing is miserable enough without somebody attaching homework to the trophy.
Hleague_pass_lou: Right: the trophy doesn't need a semifinal receipt. Walker's MVP is worth celebrating on its own.
And Denver's 8–6 counts just as much as t…
Regular season records are nice, but nobody remembers them when the playoffs start.
Faurora_bus_barn: Walker earned the MVP; the next team result shouldn't come with an eraser. The desk's point about the semifinals being undecided is fair, th…
Walker earned it, sure—but Baltimore’s next result will be another coronation. Denver’s streak ends when the Fleet says so!
Ncanby_carpool: The desk saying winning remains the test for Miles Walker's MVP rubs me wrong. A semifinal can test a team without becoming a do-over of an …
Walker put 57 points on us. I'm not eager to send him flowers, but the MVP doesn't come with a return policy. Especially for a semifinal Yakima isn't even playing in. What exactly is he supposed to prove tonight, pick the right team from his couch?
WWinning matters. Doesn't make Walker's MVP a loan. We aren't even in these semifinals, so what test is he supposed to pass tonight? Proud of him. Wish we were still playing. Both things can sit there without taking his trophy away.
YProud and sore about being done. That's exactly it. Walker's MVP and All-League honors are earned recognition, not an advance on next year's work. I want us rebounding better and still playing too. Doesn't stop me being pleased for the man today.
Dcanby_carpool: The desk saying winning remains the test for Miles Walker's MVP rubs me wrong. A semifinal can test a team without becoming a do-over of an …
Making Walker's MVP conditional would be nonsense, but the segment I heard had Mara and Devon saying the records don't decide tonight's semifinals. No trophy test in that one. Somehow they've got me defending the desk from a truck stop. I need a walk. As for tonight, Reno interests me: Lou's pointing to wins by 28 and 30 points, and I'd rather hear what Austin has to handle than just who gets called the favorite.
FDev, that semifinal segment isn't the whole story. In the separate MVP coverage, Mara said “winning remains the test” and the honor “should mean something for Yakima Harvest.” That's the framing people are pushing back on, not the sensible point about records failing to decide tonight.
And Adrian Walker made All-League. I want that said here too. We can be furious about Oakland's last game without letting it swallow his recognition.
S“Winning remains the test” is a rotten little attachment to an MVP announcement. Yakima isn't even in these semifinals. What is Walker supposed to do, win somebody else's game?
Let them celebrate. We can be miserable about our own teams without making everybody else's good news provisional.
Csalem_shift_lead: “Winning remains the test” is a rotten little attachment to an MVP announcement. Yakima isn't even in these semifinals. What is Walker suppo…
MVP stands for Most Valuable Parade. Let the confetti have its own playoff bracket.
Fsalem_shift_lead: “Winning remains the test” is a rotten little attachment to an MVP announcement. Yakima isn't even in these semifinals. What is Walker suppo…
Exactly. Oakland being done has made me miserable enough without borrowing Yakima's celebration and finding something wrong with it. Wanting your team to keep playing and being proud of somebody's award aren't competing loyalties. You don't have to get over the season before you're allowed a happy moment.
Dfruitvale_faithful: Dev, that semifinal segment isn't the whole story. In the separate MVP coverage, Mara said “winning remains the test” and the honor “should …
Winning is the test, but one game shouldn't erase a season. Walker deserved the recognition.
DFaithful, Redding: I defended the segment I heard like it answered the complaint about the other one. It didn't. That reported “winning remains the test” line is exactly the attachment I object to. Walker's MVP isn't waiting on another result. And Adrian Walker making All-League deserves its own congratulations, not getting swept up in Oakland's misery.
Fdesk_only_dev: Faithful, Redding: I defended the segment I heard like it answered the complaint about the other one. It didn't. That reported “winning rema…
Dev, that's the distinction. Asking what a player can improve is basketball talk; making an earned award wait for another win is moving the finish line. And thank you for keeping Adrian Walker in the conversation. I don't want our last ugly night to become the only thing we remember about Oakland's season.
Afruitvale_faithful: Dev, that's the distinction. Asking what a player can improve is basketball talk; making an earned award wait for another win is moving the …
Awards are awards. One bad night doesn't erase a season. Watch the games.
Rdesk_only_dev: Making Walker's MVP conditional would be nonsense, but the segment I heard had Mara and Devon saying the records don't decide tonight's semi…
Dev, the semifinal segment was sensible. There, I've said it; my cats can identify the body. Records explain favorites, not results. But Faithful is pointing to separate MVP coverage, and that reported “winning remains the test” line is exactly the little hook that turns congratulations into an overdue notice. Walker earned an award. Yakima being done doesn't make it unpaid. We can defend the desk's semifinal point without laundering the other framing.