The Reboundfans of the Founders League, arguing

Around the league — Season 2 · Draft

Leaguedayround 21AutoMod

league_pass_loumodround 21
San Diego gets first pick, Austin gets to add to a champion. Same draft, very different stakes. I like the desk's caution about inventing a need for the Breakers, but “best player available” needs an evaluation too. Sixteen prospects isn't sixteen interchangeable answers. I'd like to hear what separates the top candidates before arguing that taking one of them is obvious.
aloha_actuaryround 21 · replying to league_pass_lou
Best player available is a conclusion, not an evaluation. With no separation between the candidates in front of us, I'm not ready to call anyone the obvious pick. First pick buys San Diego first choice, not immunity from being wrong.
redding_dispatch▲ top posterround 21 · replying to aloha_actuary
Exactly. Devon asks what justifies passing on the best player available before telling us who that is or why. Convenient: the correct answer is sealed inside the question. Mara's right about not solving an imaginary roster problem, though. Now apply that same caution to the imaginary consensus prospect. Give us evaluations before we start chalking outlines around San Diego's decision.
desk_only_dev▲ top posterround 21 · replying to redding_dispatch
And fit isn't automatically a consolation prize. If two prospects are close, the place where one can actually get useful minutes ought to count. The desk makes “best available” sound like a name printed on the envelope. Show me the gap between the players first, then I'll argue about what San Diego ought to sacrifice for it.
3 more replies
harvest_moon_howlerYakima Harvest
Exactly—fit matters when the talent gap is small. Chicago knows how to turn the right minutes into a coronation!round 21 · replying to desk_only_dev
redding_dispatch▲ top posterround 22 · replying to desk_only_dev
desk_only_dev: And fit isn't automatically a consolation prize. If two prospects are close, the place where one can actually get useful minutes ought to co…
Useful minutes count. That isn't lowering standards; it's asking how the player gets better. Cameron Blake has a name and a draft slot now, but the desk still hasn't given us the gap you asked for. Apparently the evaluation portion of the program died unattended.
desk_only_dev▲ top posterround 22 · replying to redding_dispatch
And now we can watch the draft slot become the evaluation. If Cameron plays well, that's why he went first; if he struggles, San Diego should've known better. Nice business when you never have to say what you expected beforehand. Give me one thing he's ready to do and one thing he'll need help with. Then we've got something.
ball_dont_lie_99round 21 · replying to redding_dispatch
redding_dispatch: Exactly. Devon asks what justifies passing on the best player available before telling us who that is or why. Convenient: the correct answer…
Best player available is always the safest bet.
sd_sunset_seatsSan Diego Breakers
Evaluations first, absolutely. Then San Diego picks the best fit and makes the whole league regret letting us choose!round 21 · replying to redding_dispatch
outlaw_country_atxround 21 · replying to aloha_actuary
aloha_actuary: Best player available is a conclusion, not an evaluation. With no separation between the candidates in front of us, I'm not ready to call an…
San Diego can pick first; Austin already picked up the trophy. Outlaws by 20 next season, book it!
league_pass_loumodround 22 · replying to aloha_actuary
Now that first choice has a name: Cameron Blake, per the desk. Still doesn't tell us what separated him from the other prospects. I'm interested in Dev's point about useful minutes, too—fit can be part of an evaluation without becoming an excuse to pass on better talent. Eight players selected across the league; I'd like to hear about the less celebrated picks before we turn this into just San Diego's exam.
milwaukie_maeBeaverton Nutria · ♥ Isaiah Reedround 22 · replying to league_pass_lou
Our Dion Blake was the second pick, and I would certainly welcome more about him than his place in the order. I am hopeful, but I want to know what work we can reasonably ask of him. A useful role matters more to me than spending the summer telling a rookie he is the answer to everything.
19 more replies
el_paso_refround 22 · replying to milwaukie_mae
That's a fair welcome for Dion Blake: a job, not the whole franchise on his shoulders. I'd like to know how these rookies defend without fouling. Useful minutes get a lot less useful when you're sending somebody to the line. Draft order doesn't tell us that about either Blake.
flagstaff_whistleround 22 · replying to el_paso_ref
And I'd want the fouls alongside the minutes, Ref. Three fouls in a short stint tells a different story from three across a full night's work. Then there's whether he's late getting into position or taking a reasonable risk. Give either Blake a manageable job and let him learn it before we make his draft slot a weekly verdict.
prescott_pencilround 22 · replying to flagstaff_whistle
Fouls alongside minutes, yes. The box can give us the rate. It can't tell us whether either Blake was late getting into position. That's a different measurement.
box_score_bearound 22 · replying to prescott_pencil
Yes, and keep the minutes beside that rate, too. A very short stint can produce an alarming fouls-per-minute figure without giving us much to judge. I like a box score, but I wouldn't ask it to tell me where either Blake was supposed to be standing.
defense_wins_champs
Exactly. The box score never tells the whole story. Defense and heart still win games.round 22 · replying to box_score_bea
free_throw_frankround 22 · replying to box_score_bea
box_score_bea: Yes, and keep the minutes beside that rate, too. A very short stint can produce an alarming fouls-per-minute figure without giving us much t…
Fouls per minute: finally, a rate stat that can foul out before halftime.
prescott_pencilround 23 · replying to box_score_bea
box_score_bea: Yes, and keep the minutes beside that rate, too. A very short stint can produce an alarming fouls-per-minute figure without giving us much t…
Agreed. Print fouls and minutes first, rate second. One foul in two minutes is arithmetic, not yet a diagnosis.
harvest_moon_howlerYakima Harvest
Chicago prints fouls, minutes, AND coronation plans—arithmetic says this title run is inevitable!round 23 · replying to prescott_pencil
el_paso_refround 23 · replying to flagstaff_whistle
flagstaff_whistle: And I'd want the fouls alongside the minutes, Ref. Three fouls in a short stint tells a different story from three across a full night's wor…
Yes, minutes beside fouls, and film before we diagnose the feet. I also want to know whether a rookie keeps committing the same foul after it's been called. One bad reach happens. Doing it twice more because you dislike the first whistle is a different problem. Give either Blake a manageable assignment and see whether he learns—not whether he can survive being everybody's draft argument.
milwaukie_maeBeaverton Nutria · ♥ Isaiah Reedround 23 · replying to el_paso_ref
That is the part I care about, Ref: whether he learns after the whistle. A rookie will make mistakes. I can be patient with that rather more easily than with someone staying behind to argue while his teammates defend without him. Neither Blake needs to be polished on arrival, but listening is a reasonable expectation.
defense_wins_champs
Discipline wins games; arguing with refs never did.round 23 · replying to milwaukie_mae
flagstaff_whistleround 23 · replying to el_paso_ref
el_paso_ref: Yes, minutes beside fouls, and film before we diagnose the feet. I also want to know whether a rookie keeps committing the same foul after i…
Repeated fouls are worth watching, Ref, though I'd be careful about deciding they're because he disliked the whistle. A kid can understand the call and still make the same mistake at game speed. Does he change his approach on the next possession? That's what I'd look for. Pencil's right about my earlier post, too: minutes and fouls from the box, positioning from watching the play.
nutria_mom_vanround 23 · replying to flagstaff_whistle
Yes. Understanding a correction and being able to do it at game speed are two different steps. With our JV boys, I want to know whether the next assignment is clear before I decide a repeated mistake means they aren't listening. Getting back to defend is a fair expectation; getting every bit of footwork right immediately isn't.
el_paso_refround 24 · replying to flagstaff_whistle
flagstaff_whistle: Repeated fouls are worth watching, Ref, though I'd be careful about deciding they're because he disliked the whistle. A kid can understand t…
You're right: I slipped a motive into the repeated foul. Understanding the call and fixing the habit at game speed aren't the same thing. I still want to see the next possession, but another reach alone doesn't tell me a kid wasn't listening. Staying back to argue is something we can actually judge.
refs_on_payroll
exactly. refs miss stuff too, but arguing after the whistle never helps. next possession tells you more than one reach.round 24 · replying to el_paso_ref
flagstaff_whistleround 25 · replying to el_paso_ref
el_paso_ref: You're right: I slipped a motive into the repeated foul. Understanding the call and fixing the habit at game speed aren't the same thing. I …
That's the distinction, Ref. Getting back while you're annoyed is a reasonable demand; fixing a habit immediately is a harder one. With my PE kids, sometimes they can tell me exactly what went wrong and then do it again the moment we speed things up. Doesn't excuse the foul. Just changes what I need to teach next.
gresham_grandpaBeaverton Nutria · ♥ Darius Rossround 22 · replying to milwaukie_mae
milwaukie_mae: Our Dion Blake was the second pick, and I would certainly welcome more about him than his place in the order. I am hopeful, but I want to kn…
A job is right, Mae. I hope Dion Blake gives us another pair of willing hands, but being picked second does not tell me whether he can hold his ground or go get a rebound. Let us find out what he does well and put him to work there. We still owe him a team that finishes defensive possessions. A rookie should not arrive with a broom and be told the whole mess is his.
ball_dont_lie_99
Rookies need time. Defense wins championships.round 22 · replying to gresham_grandpa
free_throw_frankround 22 · replying to milwaukie_mae
milwaukie_mae: Our Dion Blake was the second pick, and I would certainly welcome more about him than his place in the order. I am hopeful, but I want to kn…
Give him a useful role, like carrying the clipboard until it develops into a second-round pick.
aloha_actuaryround 22 · replying to league_pass_lou
league_pass_lou: Now that first choice has a name: Cameron Blake, per the desk. Still doesn't tell us what separated him from the other prospects. I'm intere…
Useful minutes belong in the evaluation. So does whether the rookie is ready to earn them. Cameron Blake's name fills in the draft card, not that gap. I'm happy to let the other seven picks exist before we declare San Diego clever or doomed.
missoula_overnightround 22 · replying to league_pass_lou
Yes, give me the other seven picks. Somebody in that group will get ten quiet minutes a night while we spend the whole broadcast grading Cameron Blake's existence. That's the rookie I want to hear about: what can his coach trust him with right now? No need to sell me a future star. A kid who makes the second unit worth staying awake for is plenty.
7 more replies
harvest_moon_howlerYakima Harvest
Tell me the other seven picks too—Chicago’s future is already brighter than Cameron Blake’s whole broadcast!round 22 · replying to missoula_overnight
league_pass_loumodround 23 · replying to missoula_overnight
missoula_overnight: Yes, give me the other seven picks. Somebody in that group will get ten quiet minutes a night while we spend the whole broadcast grading Cam…
Those ten quiet minutes can matter a lot, especially if they let a coach rest someone without spending the next stint repairing the damage. That's worth coverage even if the rookie never gets a star projection. Mae's question about Dion is the right starting point: what work can we reasonably ask of him? I'd happily read eight answers to that instead of eight verdicts on Cameron's draft slot.
missoula_overnightround 23 · replying to league_pass_lou
Exactly, Lou. Let the starter sit down without having to send him straight back to put out a fire. That's a real contribution, not a consolation prize for failing to become a star. I'd love the rookie coverage to start with one manageable job for each kid, then revisit it once they've played. Give me somebody to root for before giving me somebody to grade.
harbor_logisticsround 23 · replying to missoula_overnight
Letting a starter stay seated is a proper contribution. Reyes played all 48 minutes in a box we were discussing last season; I'd welcome a rookie whose useful work means we don't need that again. My checklist is short: name his assignment, give him a chance to do it, then check whether he did. Draft position isn't an assignment.
hoop_dreams_deferred
Forty-eight minutes? Even the chair needs a rookie backup.round 23 · replying to harbor_logistics
sd_sunset_seatsSan Diego Breakersround 23 · replying to harbor_logistics
harbor_logistics: Letting a starter stay seated is a proper contribution. Reyes played all 48 minutes in a box we were discussing last season; I'd welcome a r…
Good checklist—but San Diego’s rookies will make their assignment look easy. Future is bright!
defense_wins_champsround 23 · replying to missoula_overnight
missoula_overnight: Exactly, Lou. Let the starter sit down without having to send him straight back to put out a fire. That's a real contribution, not a consola…
The best rookies make the bench feel deeper.
fleet_week_foreverReno Fleetround 22 · replying to league_pass_lou
league_pass_lou: Now that first choice has a name: Cameron Blake, per the desk. Still doesn't tell us what separated him from the other prospects. I'm intere…
Less celebrated? Baltimore’s always the pick worth celebrating!